Some people said this movie is the most controversial movie ever made in Malaysia. Thye said that if we watch this movie people might be 'terpesong'. They gave the comments before the watch this movie. But for me after watching this movie, there's no single thing yang leh memesongkan akidah seseorang. So don't simply give your judgement before you watch it.

I watched this movie on it first day release since i waited for it for so long after read different comments and different perspective for those who already watch it. Two words after watched it- DIFFERENT and SIMPLE.

I love the way arwah YAsmin Ahmad (YA) portray the beauty of religions no matter Islam, Chritian or any other religions. Mesej yang penting dalam movie nie- Semua agama menganjurkan sikap yang positif dalam diri dan tiada satu agama pu n yang menyuruh ke arah keburukan.

The best parts ....

• how close Rohana and Rohani. They support each other.
• Sikap pemaaf both of them before diorg tido which is one of perangai YA before she went to sleep. Kekadang aku terpikir kat diri aku. Adakah aku jenis pemaaf? Honestly i'm not that kind of person.
• Minum arak yang mmg terbukti haram. But at the same time he didn't want to shake hand with someone who just touch a dog. He did the haram thing but he know that pegang anjing tu haram. It's happen to us. We know something is not right but we still do the wrong things in different way. Irony is it?
• Watak Brain yang confuse gk menarik perhatian aku. Seorang guru sejarah yang suruh students nya jadikan sejarah sebagai rujukan diri. But at the same time, dia hukum his mum for the history that he should learned from it. However he ignore that his 'sejarah' tu yang sepatut nya menjadikan dia lebih matang. Unfortunately kematangan untuk memaafkan manusia tersayang tidak digunakan sebaik2 nya.
• Sikap Rohana and Rohani untuk mendalami agama dan kesediaan mereka untuk mencari guru untuk mendapat kepastian tentang agama memang wonderful. Just imagine they willing to learn religions from yang berpengetahuan but majority of us sendiri tak mahu mendalami Islam tu dengan mendalam dan selalu menbuat kesimpulan sendiri tanpa merujuk kepada orang cerdik pandai.

Sebenarnya banyak perkara yang leh di bincangkan mengenai filem ini. Benda yang tersirat melebihi tersurat. Filem yang memerlukan pemikiran dan ilmu yang agak tinggi.

As i said it's SIMPLE movie because of the issue yang di bangkitkan tetapi penilaian nya perlu di perhalusi sedit demi sedikit. Sejujurnya aku tak puas untuk mengupas filem ini kerana keistimewaan isu yang di tampilkan

Personally this is one of YA bes film but I prefer talentime. People might say that this movie quite slow and mendatar jer but aku xkisah psl tu la identity YA. Takkan nak sama ngan filem orang lain kot. Per2 pun aku mmg puas ngan movie ni n penantian aku selama ni berbaloi.

p/s- at the ned of this movie, i realized that this is YA's last movie that I able to watch. Love her art and touch. Her movies will still remain the best until forever. No one can replace her place and talent. Al Fatihah to Allahyarhamah Yasmin Ahmad.

Labels: my.review